Good engineers struggle as managers because the habits that made them great at the work slow a team down when they lead it.
Most new managers start with no preparation
Your firm promoted its best engineer into management. Six months later, projects stall, the team waits on one person, and a good engineer hands in their notice. All three trace back to the same move: the firm rewarded expertise, then asked for leadership.
82% of people who step into management in the UK have had no formal management or leadership training. Source: Chartered Management Institute with YouGov, October 2023
Managers account for at least 70% of the variance in employee engagement across business units. Source: Gallup
The manager shapes much of a team’s engagement, and most new UK managers start with no formal preparation. In technical teams that gap shows up as stalled projects, burnt-out leads and good people who leave. In Australia it carries a legal edge too. Every state and territory now has psychosocial duties in its workplace safety law, and workload, conflict and poor support sit on that list. The same patterns show up in consultants, finance and legal professionals promoted for their expertise.
The three habits we see most
1. The expert who can’t let go
Engineers earn their reputation by having the answer. As managers, they keep giving it. Someone brings a problem, the manager solves it, and the team learns to wait. The manager becomes the bottleneck, works longer hours and still falls behind.
What it sounds like: “It’s faster if I just do it.”
2. Treating people problems as technical problems
Engineering rewards logic and evidence. So new managers try to solve people problems the same way: find the right answer, prove it, move on. A team member who feels unheard doesn’t change their mind because the argument held up. The manager wins the debate and loses the person.
What it sounds like: “I explained it three times. Why won’t they just do it?”
3. Lost without the output
An engineer’s sense of worth often comes from what they produce: a design, a calculation, a solved problem. A manager’s work shows less. Conversations, decisions and other people’s progress don’t feel like output. So new managers drift back into technical work where they feel useful, and the leading waits.
What it sounds like: “I didn’t get anything done today. I was in meetings all day.”
Why most leadership courses don’t change habits
Many firms respond with a leadership course. Too often it asks technical people to act: project confidence, be more expressive, role-play a difficult conversation in front of colleagues. A rigorous mind reads that as fake. Many engineers switch off, collect the certificate and go back to the same habits. More on this in why leadership is not performance.
What changes how a technical leader leads
Three things work for technical people because they treat leadership as a skill you learn with evidence.
- See how you lead. In a group simulation under real pressure, people stop acting. You see your own habits in action, and so does your facilitator.
- Understand why. A good assessment explains the traits behind your behaviour, when they help, when they hurt, and your impact on your team.
- Practise on real work. Learn a model, use it on your own projects, review what happened, then adjust. Repeat until it becomes a habit.
We call this the Authenticity Cycle: Reveal, Explain, Develop. More than 100 leaders in one electrical engineering business went through our Coaching for Performance program and rated it NPS 75. 75% were promoters and none were detractors. For people in their first years of leading, start with From Accidental to Authentic.
From accidental to authentic.
Questions about engineers as managers
Why do engineers make bad managers?
Plenty make strong managers. Engineers struggle at first because the habits that made them strong engineers, like owning the answer and perfecting detail, slow a team down. Few get any preparation for the people side. With the right support, they grow into excellent leaders.
What is the biggest challenge for a new engineering manager?
Letting go of being the person with the answer. Their value moves from what they produce to what their team produces. That means delegating, coaching and giving feedback.
How can engineers become better managers?
Practise leadership like any other skill. See how you lead under pressure, understand why, then practise new habits on real work with feedback. Simulations, an assessment and coaching all help.
Should every good engineer become a manager?
No. Some firms offer a technical career path alongside the management one. Engineers who choose management need real support for the people side of the job.
Found this useful? Share it with your team.
